Audi vs. BMW vs. Mercedes – Which One is for YOU 2023?

If you are in the market to buy luxury cars, then you must be looking at the German car market as well. German cars, especially Audi, Mercedes, and BMW, are known to be luxurious. However, they don’t offer just luxury but also comfort and reliability- if we ignore some of the issues regarding that department.

All of these German-made vehicles have the same luxury, superior engine performance, and proven durability. Customer preferences in these three areas will determine which car brands are the best. Overall, a car buyer cannot go wrong with any of these three options.

All three manufacturers provide a broad selection of cars, from the least expensive (starting at around $30,000) to those with up to and above 12 cylinders and prices in the mid-to-upper-$150,000 range. First, let’s evaluate the current standing of each brand.

BMW ranked #1 of 32 on Consumer Reports’ best car brands for 2023, beating both Audi and Mercedes, which came in the 9th and 26th positions, respectively. BMW performed well in road test scores, reliability, and owner satisfaction survey results, making it the best German car brand for 2023.

An Overview of Their Remarkable Histories: Audi, BMW, and Mercedes

image credit: Manu B

There is no denying the depth of history shared by these three brands. This history can sometimes be traced back hundreds of years.

In the year 1884, in particular, Mercedes was the first automobile manufacturer to appear on the market and the first of the brands to establish its presence. After that, in 1909, Audi entered the scene, and then in 1916, BMW did.

When it comes to the interiors of its vehicles, in particular, the Audi brand is dedicated to the presentation of a luxurious aesthetic. Audi pays meticulous attention to every facet of a car, regardless matter how seemingly minor it may seem. However, their attention to detail is faced head-to-head with the dominant presence of Mercedes, another brand noted for the grandeur of its interiors, the strength of its engines, and the smoothness of its rides.

Lastly, there’s BMW, a true up-and-comer in this industry. BMW strongly emphasizes the driving experience itself, particularly the enjoyment that can be derived from agile handling on winding roads. The growth in demand for these particular models can be attributed to the production brand’s decision to expand its SUV lineup. A younger demographic is typically drawn to BMW because of its dedication to creating an enjoyable driving experience.

Taking all of this into consideration, which brand can boast the most illustrious history? Which of these will lend some prestige to your acquisition? Is it a Mercedes, a BMW, or an Audi? To tell you the truth, all three.

These automobile manufacturers are, without a shadow of a doubt, equally seasoned competitors when it comes to the building of automobiles.

The best Interior, Exterior, and Technology: Audi, BMW, or Mercedes?

image credit: Sven Mieke

Several substantial distinctions between these brands may be seen in the external and interior detailing of their products.

As a manufacturer of automobiles, Audi places a significant emphasis on elegance, as evidenced by the company’s use of high-end upholstery for its seating, as well as the incorporation of some remarkable technological innovations. When you see an Audi from the outside, you can typically identify it by its recognizable four-ring logo and its smooth curves.

Imagine a car with precise bodywork and a grille design like twin kidneys when you think of a BMW. Inside, you’ll find seating equivalent to what you’d find in an Audi, albeit perhaps a little less opulent and more centered on convenience. However, when it comes to technological features, BMW shines. A significant example? Newer models of the BMW X3 Series come equipped with a standard infotainment touchscreen measuring 10.2 inches, blind-spot tracking, and lane departure warnings as standard features.

Last but not least is Mercedes-Benz, known for producing iconic cars. This car manufacturer is always concerned with both raw power and a high level of refinement. For instance, if you purchase one of the more recent base models of the CLA 250 Class, you may anticipate finding leather upholstery, leather and metallic steering wheel, and leatherette door trim.

The best SUV: Audi, BMW, or Mercedes?

image credit: Nick van der Ende

Due to the fact that Mercedes-Benz was the first company to market a premium SUV in 1998, the company enjoyed a few years without any competition. Despite this, the company was slow to recognize the trend toward smaller-sized SUVs and crossover vehicles. As a direct consequence, BMW has dominated the SUV market for the better half of a decade. In contrast, Mercedes-Benz has been forced to play catch-up, mainly as a result of the unsatisfactory design decision made for the GLK. 

Even though Audi was late to the party and all of its offers are still in their first generation, the company has had a lot of success in Europe with its SUVs and crossovers. Audi noticed that even if customers value the utility of a crossover, the majority of them prefer for it to look more feminine and trendy as opposed to tough and capable. This led to the development of an appealing design, one of the key drivers. Because of this, the brand has been at the top of the overall premium charts continuously since 2009.

The most reliable: Audi, BMW, or Mercedes?

image credit: Blake Meyer

There are very few things about an automobile that is more crucial than its reliability. Each of these manufacturers has high-powered turbo engines that are capable of producing hundreds of horsepower in addition to advanced driver assistance safety systems that will keep you out of scrapes. However, Consumer Reports has ranked one of them higher than the others in terms of dependability.

According to the results of the research on vehicle dependability that Consumer Reports conducted for 2022, the Audi brand came in at number fifteen, ranking higher than both BMW and Mercedes-Benz. BMW is now ranked #17, two spots below Audi, while Mercedes-Benz has slid to #23.

Audi comes out on top as the brand you can rely on the most to endure for the most extended period.

Better in Terms of Safety and Handling:  Audi, BMW, or Mercedes?

image credit; Håkon Sataøen

When it comes to these three car manufacturers, how do they rate in terms of safety and handling?

To begin, you should expect Audi to place emphasis on all-wheel drive, which will make their vehicles trustworthy in a variety of climatic conditions. In addition, because of its generally more rigid suspension, Audi’s on-road handling could be more agile than BMW’s. Nevertheless, regarding safety ratings, Audi boasts some of the best.

When contrasting the dependability of Audi and BMW, you should anticipate more nimble handling from the latter and place more emphasis on response. Because newer BMW models come with the option to incorporate an all-wheel-drive system, these vehicles are fantastic choices for driving in icier climates because of this feature. When it comes to safety ratings, BMW is on par with Audi in every way.

And then, there’s Mercedes-Benz, which equips most of its vehicles with all-wheel drive as standard. When it comes to priorities, Mercedes prioritizes safety. In fact, they have been leaders in the auto safety industry for such a long time that they were instrumental in developing “crumple zones” in automobiles during the 1950s. Because of this feature, a vehicle can better protect the people inside of it in the event of an accident by absorbing some of the force of the hit.

Which one is for me: Audi, BMW, or Mercedes?

image credit: Fernando Marques

The exceptional features that separate these three are determined by how the customer perceives those features. But what if you are a consumer of cars who places a high value on having a good time behind the wheel? If such is the case, you should purchase a BMW. Regarding “fun and thrilling,” BMW is a brand that takes things to a new level as far as its approach is concerned. Above all else, they want the drive to be user-friendly and versatile in its design.

But a Mercedes is an excellent option to consider if you are looking for safety in addition to speed and power. Mercedes is all about high status and making a statement. Their high quality is reflected in the mechanics of their cars, which frequently have large, strong engines capable of quickly getting you up to speed.

But if the outside appearance of a vehicle is the factor that influences your decision the most, then you should consider purchasing an Audi. With a few exceptions, Audi is recognized for its quiet engines: their appreciation of elegance extends into the mechanics themselves.


Making an objective decision between BMW, Mercedes, and Audi is impossible, at least in certain respects. Different people have varying preferences, requirements, and price ranges. Consequently, arriving at one of these three options is primarily dependent on one’s own personal preferences rather than on any objective criteria.

Even though the three different manufacturers have converged in many respects over the course of their respective histories, each of them still maintains its own individual identity and possesses its own set of distinctive attributes. 

Customers looking for luxury should consider purchasing a Mercedes, while those looking for driving pleasure should consider purchasing a BMW. Audi is positioned in the middle and offers a mix of the two by combining a slick design with a significant amount of cutting-edge technology. Your choices will determine which option is best for you now that you have an overview of the benefits that come with selecting each brand.

4 15 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments